By Michael O'Leary; The Regimental Rogue
Paul Marsden, in his paper Shaping the Canadian Record of War in the 20th Century, relates the cirecumstances which resulted in the current holdings of First World War service records at Library and Archives Canada.
Lt.-Col. Logie Armstrong, who assumed the title of Director of Records at the end of the war, … was particularly keen on this means of reducing files, claiming that the personnel files, each consisting of an overseas file and a headquarters file could be reduced to something like fifty percent of its original volume. … the Public Archives. Shortly after the Archives opened its new wing, in what is currently the Canadian War Museum, DND took the opportunity to unburden itself of the entirety of the CEF service and subject files from the OMFC and CEF. … On 1 April 1930, after much negotiation, DND transferred the records to the control of the Public Archives. … The list of actual decisions by the Public Records Committee to destroy files is a long one. However, in the context of this study there are some notable cases. As indicated above, the service files of the CEF had been transferred to custody of the Public Archives in 1930. On March 23rd 1948 the committee decided that all wartime service files would be transferred to the Department of Veterans Affairs (DVA). Colonel H.M. Jackson, then of DVA, opined that the files had no archival value and, thus, the decision was taken to allow the stripping of them. As a result, the two parts, headquarters and overseas, were consolidated by the War Service Records Division of DVA down into the single thin envelope of forms which survives today.
Shaping the Canadian Record of War in the 20th Century, published in the Canadian Military History Since the 17th Century (Proceedings of the Canadian Military History Conference, Ottawa, 5-9 May 2000)
The result of bureaucratic decision making, conflicting requirements and expectations of government departments, and the fact that the cost of destroying the files was never undertaken by agencies responsible for them, we have the benefit of the surviving records. What remains is the combined files , ie., the Overseas Miltary Forces files with Ottawa's files, for each soldier. The saved documents are generally the paperwork related to record of service, pay, pension and medical history, although other items may be found in any particular file.
While there are dozens of different forms that may appear in each service record, some will form the core elements of further research. Firstly, there are the record of service documents. While these may be found written on any form that came to hand, they will invariably be identified by their five columns of information:
Excerpted sample of a record of service document from the CEF service record of 488229 Private John Garfield Roberts.
The main record column, combined with the second date column, will form the central thread of the soldier's wartime history. Transcribing these and ordering them chronologically will establish dates of movements between units, periods in hospital if any, leave, and all other aspects of military life that were required to be reported to the main headquarters for the OMFC.
While that task seems simple in context, it can be challenging as you start to look over seemingly endless streams of abbreviations and short forms of unit names. But you are not the first on this path. While these instructions are a very light overview of the research you are undertaking, the members of the Canadian Expeditionary Force Study Group (CEFSG) have collected much information that will help as specific questions arise. The CEFSG, in the form of an online forum, includes a message board section specific to Service Records and, for an excellent starting point, a comprehensive and ever-growing list of Acronyms & Abbreviations found in CEF Service Records and War Diaries.
The Record of Service sheets will appear jumbled at first. This is the effect of having the two sets of documents (the Overseas file and the Ottawa headquarters file) put together in the one saved service record file. As you transcribe them you may find items that are recorded in one document set but not the other. A majority of items will appear twice, but any item may have a little more information on one record sheet than another.
Transfers. Movements between units, where the soldier is Struck off Strength (S.O.S.) of one unit and immediately Taken on Strength (T.O.S.) of a new unit.
Promotions. These may be noted as with or without the associated pay increase. See Part 11: Rank, no simple progression.
Demotions. These may also referred to as Reversions and were not always a bad thing. Although it could be a punishment, it was as often the result of a man accepting a reduction in rank to proceed overseas to France from a training or reserve unit in England. See Part 11: Rank, no simple progression.
Courts Martial. The formal trials of soldiers for crimes committed on active service. Some entries in a service record may note punishments (Mulct Pay, Forfeitures of Pay, Field Punishments) without a Court Martial, and those are the results of summary trials held before a Company Commander or Commanding Officer. Courts Martial, on the other hand, left a much more complete record, and these too can be ordered from Library and Archives Canada. See Part 3: Court Martial Records.
Hospitalizations. Men were hospitalized for sickness, accidental injury or for wounds received in action. Periods of hospitalization and subsequent recovery could be lengthy, lasting many months, even when we might today recover quickly with the benefits of modern antibiotics and other medicines. Soldiers might progress through a series of hospitals in moving from the front lines rearward, including transhipment to England by Hospital Ship, until they reached a longer term care facility.
Details of death. If the soldier was a casualty overseas, then some details of death may be recorded in his file. See Part 5: Casualties.
Medical documents in the service records can range from file cards noting admissions to hospital, to examination and treatment records, to examination on discharge from the CEF. These can provide a record of movements through the medical system, from the Casualty Clearing Stations near the front lines to the Convalescent Hospitals in the English countryside.
Diseases and treatments may be cause for extra research, as the naming of ailments and the noted treatments may not be the same today. Occasionally, a family researcher may want to seek out the advice of a medical professional for a more detailed understanding of their ancestor's medical conditions and the care they experienced.
Sample of a hospital admissions record card from the CEF service record of 733157 Private Robert Watson.
CEF service records will usually still contain pay ledger sheets and any documents related to final settlement of pay account and pensions or gratuities awarded at the end of the soldier's service. Pay ledgers may include the names and addresses of next-of-kin that were awarded Pay Allotments (i.e., money sent home to wife, mother, or other designated recipient.)
A more detailed examination of pay ledgers may reveal deductions for lost equipment when the loss was through negligence, minor fines such as for being absent without leave, or the loss of 50 cents per day plus field allowances while in hospital for venereal disease. While 50 cents per day may not sound like much to us today, that was half the daily rate of pay for a Private soldier.
Excerpted sample of a pay ledger from the CEF service record of 488229 Private John Garfield Roberts.
Other interesting tidbits may include large withdrawal from a soldier's pay account as he goes on leave to Paris or England, or the possibility that he seldom drew cash from his pay account and left the Army with a large sum of pay in hand.
An excellent online resource providing examples of the many different documents that may be found in CEF service records is available at Brett Payne's CEF Paper Trail. The following, from his introduction, outlines the aim of his project:
"The first phase of this project has involved the collating of examples of each type of document found in a soldier's World War 1 Canadian Expeditionary Force Service Records. Here you will find a preliminary selection, and I would like to encourage other researchers to contribute more. The guide is designed partly to show prospective researchers what they can expect to find in a soldiers' service records, and partly to answer questions that I have had from fellow researchers wanting to know how they, too, can find out more of their particular soldier's military service. It's important to be aware that you will only find a selection of these records in your particular CEF soldier's file. Please note that some of these images will take a while to download if you are still on dial-up access."
Starting in 2013, Library and Archives Canada has begun digitizing the First World War service records. Vavailable digital files can be found through the Personnel Records of the First World War (1914-1918) database. (387676 digitial service records are available as of 14 Jan 2017, with the digitization project up to the "M" surnames.)
Library and Archives Canada Personnel Records of the First World War (1914-1918) database search result, an individual result showing the link to the digitized copy of the soldier's service record. See the digitized file for 433020 Private William Kerr Chalmers.
of the First World War
Now available from the
Amazon Kindle Store.
• The "Man-in-the-Dark" Theory of Infantry Tactics and the "Expanding Torrent" System of Attack, by Captain B.H. Lidell-Hart, K.O.Y.L.I.