By Michael O'Leary; The Regimental Rogue
If you ask four collectors and researchers the definition of a medal group, you will end up with at least five explanations. In simplistic terms with regard to First World War medals, the term "group" is usually used to refer to all of a soldier's medals taken together, and comprised of his "pair" or "trio" plus other medals.
Many visitors to these pages will have been prompted to learn more about an ancestor's service in the First World War with the Canadian Expeditionary Force because of medals. Those medals might still be with the family; either kept as treasured heirlooms or recently found deep in a drawer or trunk, or they may be long gone from the family; lost, sold or (more rarely) stolen and adrift in the wide wide world. So often tales are seen of rediscovered medals, previously unknown to the family members who have found them, resting deep in an old trunk, carefully placed in a commemorative biscuit tin or other receptacle, perhaps still mounted as the returned soldier wore then, or sometimes still in the small boxes in which they were received, and never worn.
Of those many medals that have left the original families, most did so under honourable circumstances; from being sold in house auctions at the death of the last of the family line that held them, or sold during hard times to feed hungry children (an apocryphal anecdote usually applied to a missing silver British War Medal, or one that has been found separated from its fellows). Some were sold by their recipient for whom they brought only memories of death and suffering, because Post-Traumatic Syndrome Disorder (PTSD) is by no means a modern affliction, or as it was known in the Great War era: "Shell Shock". But all is not lost, with luck and perseverance some of those wandering medals find their way back to the original families, usually with gratitude expressed toward the last of a line of collectors who preserved their heritage and treated their relationship to the medals as custodians of a soldier's story. Think not poorly of those collectors who spend time, money and effort to care for medals in their collections, often researching the men they belonged to and learning their stories. No man spends hundred or thousands of dollars on medals as an act to "dishonour" soldiers and if these medals had not been preserved by so many collectors, they would have disappeared long ago as one more "old thing" lacking any value in society.
For a new researcher (or an old one), whether family or regimental, to hold a soldier's medals in ones hand is to touch a physical artifact of his service. Even though they were issued after the fact, sometimes years after the close of the soldier's service record, medals remain a tangible link to that past and concrete evidence of the steps he took in heavy boots in service to his nation.
But where to begin? I suppose we should start by looking in the biscuit tin.
Note: Linked medal names will lead to pages at the Veterans Affairs Canada site which will provide descriptions and details of eligibility for each medal.
The British War Medal and Victory Medal "pair" awarded to 477915 Private Albert Morley Thomas of The Royal Canadian Regiment.
Since we're mainly focused on researching a soldier of the First World War, we'll start with what's most likely in the tin. There's probably two medals at least, a silver one and a gold coloured one. Each might have an attached ribbon, the silver medal's ribbon would be mainly orange with blue edges and the gold medal would have a rainbow striped ribbon, red in the centre and purple on the edges. These two, the most common issued to soldiers of the Canadian Expeditionary Force are the British War Medal and the Victory Medal. If there is a third medal, a star-shaped one, it will probably be the 1914-1915 Star. We'll address these three before we move on to other, less common medals that may also be in the tin.
The 1914-1915 Star, the British War Medal and the Victory Medal are the most common medal issued to Canadian soldiers in the Great War. The latter two are the more common of the three, because to receive the 1914-15 Star required the soldier to have reached the front lines before 31 December 1915. Because of this, soldiers who enlisted later in the war received only the latter two.
For each medal, check the back of the star and the lower edge of the discs for the soldier's service number, name and unit impressed (i.e., die-struck, not engraved) into the metal.
Because nothing is simple, even with the purported regimentation of military bureaucracy, even these three basic medals are subject to special cases. I shall not dwell on such details, but it is helpful to identify that unique cases exist:
Those three medals, the 1914-1915 Star, the British War Medal and the Victory Medal are sometimes referred to as "Pip, Squeak and Wilfred", a soldier's nickname for them, after the characters in a British newspaper cartoon strip (which was published starting in 1919).
Let's look at the possible components of an officer's or soldier's medal group, which, depending on length of service and specific activities, could include any of the following:
Depending on what other medals (if any) you have with the soldier's First World War service medals, if any, will determine what other particulars of service you may need to investigate. For any that were also awarded during the Great War, your best starting point remains the soldier's service record. For Honours and Awards, you will find some additional research guidance at this page
The First World War Medal group awarded to 477781 Corporal Arthur Rix of The Royal Canadian Regiment. Rix's medal group consists of the Military Medal (for bravery in the field), the India General Service Medal (for pre-War service in the British Army) the 1914-1915 Star, the British War Medal and the Victory Medal.
Before we go on, let's examine some basic medal terminology. Understanding these terms will help when you go one to explore Great War or Medal Forums, such as Canadian Expeditionary Force Study Group, the Great War Forum and the British Medal Forum for more information.
Group - If you ask four collectors and researchers the definition of a medal group, you will end up with at least five explanations. In simplistic terms with regard to First World War medals, the term "group" is usually used to refer to all of a soldier's medals taken together, and comprised of his "pair" or "trio" plus other medals.
Trio - Pip, Squeak and Wilfred - the basic trio of First World War medals; the 1914-1915 Star, the British War Medal and the Victory Medal. The term "trio" refers to these three, while other combinations of three would be a described as a "group."
Pair - The British War Medal and the Victory Medal, the standard pair of medals issued to soldiers who served at the front but did not arrive early enough for a "Star."
Single - The only First World War medal of the trio that was issued alone is the British War Medal, and if this is a soldier's full entitlement it could (irreverently) be called his group (to the consternation of the pedants among collectors). A "single" may also refer to an individual medal which has become separated from its pair, trio or group. Many soldiers' medals were divided among family as individual mementos.
Broken Group - A broken group refers to any part of a soldier's full entitlement, from a separated single to any but his full entitlement of medals.
Bar - Bars, signifying second awards, were worn on the ribbons of decorations (i.e, valour awards). To state that a man was "MM and bar" is to say that he was awarded the Military medal twice during his service.
MiD - MiD, or "Mention in Despatches"; soldiers who actions were brought to the attention of the King by their commanders, but not sufficiently significant to be recommended for a decoration might be awarded a Mention in Despatches. The recipient of one (or more) MiDs was entitled to wear a small oak leaf emblem on the ribbon of the Victory Medal (or the British War Medal if the Victory Medal was not awarded).
Swing Mounted - A manner of mounting medals for wear used at the time of the First World War, in which each medal swings freely below a hanging bar.
Court Mounted - A style of mounting medals in which each medal and ribbon is fixed to a rigid backing. Most modern medal mounters, who may remount your medals for display, will be more experienced in this technique. Some state that it is a more presentable design, and that the manner of fixing each medal in place eliminates the possibility of damage by the knocking edges of adjacent medals.
During the First World War the families of soldiers who died as result of their service (killed in action, died of wounds, injury, sickness or accident) received memorial items in addition to the soldiers' entitlement of medals. For medallic items, these consisted of the Memorial Cross and the Memorial Plaque. Certain collectors consider a casualty's medal group to be "complete" only if issued Memorial Cross(es) and Plaque are kept with the medals.
The Memorial Cross was fashioned of sterling silver and impressed on the reverse with the soldier's service number, rank, name and (if any) post-nominals designating received honours. Crosses were sent to a deceased soldier's mother (if she was still alive) and to his wife (if he was married). Based on this there may be one, two or no Memorial Crosses awarded for any particular casualty.
The Memorial Cross sent to the next-of-kin of 477609 Private Clifford Moss, M.M. of The Royal Canadian Regiment.
The Memorial Plaque was fashioned of bronze, about 5 inches (120 mm) in diameter and cast with the soldiers name as part of the face of the plaque. The plaque was sent to the soldier's next-of-kin, regardless of whether or not Memorial Crosses were issued.
The Memorial Cross sent to the next-of-kin of 477501 Private Henry William Krimmell, a soldier of of The Royal Canadian Regiment who died accidentally while serving with the 7th Canadian Light Trench Mortar Battery.
The CEF soldier's service record will normally include a copy of his medal card. Though cryptic, this card will show what medals and memorial items were awarded. Commonly, the issue of the Britsh War Medal and Victory Medal are shown on these cards by a large hand-written "B" and "V", each with a check-mark through them.
The medal card in the service record of 478516 Private Walter Hanam. Note that Hanam was not eligible for the 1914-15 Star but was awarded the Victory Medal and the British War Medal. For memorial items, no Memorial Cross was issued (unmarried and mother likely predeceased), a Memorial Plaque was despatched on 30 March 1922 a Memorial Scroll followed on 5 April 1922.
Depending on the nature of his service, a soldier would receive a War Service Badge on leaving the Army. This could be worn on his civilian jacket lapel to show others, such as potential employers, that he was a returned soldier.
The contents of the small box that contained 739068 Private George Cowdery's medals and associated items. Included are Cpl Cowdery's British War Medal and Victory Medal (with reversed ribbons), his stripes denoting four years of wartime service, regimental cap badge for The Royal Canadian Regiment, Lewis Gunner trade badge, "R.C.R. shoulder titles, "Canada" shoulder titles, wound stripe and his War Service badge. Also found in the box were the buttons and belt hooks from his great coat.
of the First World War
Now available from the
Amazon Kindle Store.
• The "Man-in-the-Dark" Theory of Infantry Tactics and the "Expanding Torrent" System of Attack, by Captain B.H. Lidell-Hart, K.O.Y.L.I.